Showing posts with label Keynes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Keynes. Show all posts

Tuesday, October 5, 2010

Neoclassical Economics Are to Henry George What Neoliberal Economics are to John Maynard Keynes

I recently learnd about Henry George, a 19th century thinker who figured out in the 1870s that the boom-bust cycle is caused by debt-financed speculation and rent seeking.  At the time, he limited his conclusion to debt-financed land speculation, but that's because the secondary equity and bond markets weren't nearly as established in the 1870s as they were in 1907 and later in 1929.  (Note: there are a number of 19th century investing texts available at Google Books, and they show that the stock exchanges even in the 1890s were nowhere near what they became by the 1920s.  Take a look around there, you'll find it fascinating.)

As Keynes would later do, George proposed his own solution for euthanizing the rentier, which he called the "Single Tax."  (My understanding of George's proposal are admittedly cursory, so I'm not going to try to explain them in any kind of detail.)

The response by the rentiers was to fund political economists to develop a new doctrine of political economy, and neoclassical economics was born (at least, this is what Mr. George believed motivated the establishment of this new doctrine).

The key feature of neoclassical economics was that it treated land as capital.  According to the classical economics of Smith, Ricardo, Say et al., there were three players in (or drivers of) the economy: labor, land and capital.  Essentially, George's Single Tax sought to tax land rents out of existence to leave only labor and capital standing.  The neoclassical economists obliged George by "disappearing" land from their lexicon and treating it merely as another form of capital.

Neoclassical economics came to dominate the scene, and George's Single Tax proposal ultimately went nowhere.

Then we had the Great Depression, and John Maynard Keynes offered his own solution to the rentier problem (although he was politic enough to not explicitly assign blame for the Great Depression to the financial speculators). 

The first step in undermining Keynes was the so-called "neoclassical synthesis," that grafted some of Keynes' ideas onto neoclassical doctrine.

The second step in undermining Keynes was to repeat what had been done to Henry George: the rentiers funded the founding of the neoliberal movement and its economics in the Chicago and Austrian schools. 

Today's "neoclassical" orthodoxy is, in fact, the Chicago School, which is distinctly neoliberal.  Thus, as much as Steve Keen still labels the orthodoxy neoclassical, it is more appropriate to label it neoliberal.

Where neoclassical economics whittled the economic drivers from three (labor, land and capital) to two (labor and capital), neoliberal economics left us with only capital.  There is no labor any longer.  There are only consumers.  And the rentier segment of capital is the only part of it that continues to grow.

Monday, September 13, 2010

Keynes' Real Sin

Many negative things have been said about John Maynard Keynes, most of them with regard to the school of economic thought that bears his name but little resemblance to his actual work: Keynesianism.  Most recently, people have laid the blame for Nixon closing the gold window at Keynes' feet (in spite of the fact that it was Chicago School monetarists Milton Friedman and Paul Volcker who championed that move) as well as the blame for the ongoing financial crisis (in spite of the fact that it was brought on by financial deregulation urged by Chicago School economists like Milton Friedman). 

In spite of all the breathless accusations of Keynes' evil influence over Washington elites, remarkably little of Keynes' work remains publicly available or accessible.  Only a couple of his books remain in print, although biographies by people like Hyman Minsky provide some sense of what these lost works say.  The fact is that Washington D.C. abandoned Keynesianism in 1980 to embrace the neoliberal Washington Consensus, which is informed by Chicago School economic thought (what I call "ponzinomics").

So why has Keynes become a political pinata, his legacy taking a beating for something he had no hand in?

The answer most likely found in Chapter 24 of The General Theory, in which he wrote: 
Now, though this state of affairs would be quite compatible with some measure of individualism, yet it would mean the euthanasia of the rentier, and, consequently, the euthanasia of the cumulative oppressive power of the capitalist to exploit the scarcity-value of capital. Interest today rewards no genuine sacrifice, any more than does the rent of land. The owner of capital can obtain interest because capital is scarce, just as the owner of land can obtain rent because land is scarce. But whilst there may be intrinsic reasons for the scarcity of land, there are no intrinsic reasons for the scarcity of capital. An intrinsic reason for such scarcity, in the sense of a genuine sacrifice which could only be called forth by the offer of a reward in the shape of interest, would not exist, in the long run, except in the event of the individual propensity to consume proving to be of such a character that net saving in conditions of full employment comes to an end before capital has become sufficiently abundant. But even so, it will still be possible for communal saving through the agency of the State to be maintained at a level which will allow the growth of capital up to the point where it ceases to be scarce.
Many economists before Keynes had deplored the rentiers and financial speculators, including Adam Smith, but no mainstream economist had taken aim at euthanizing them for fear of being euthanized.  Economists before and since Keyenes studiously ignore the rentier class and its deliterious effect on the real economy, pretending instead that there is only labor and capital, only supply and demand, only two parties who barter, in the "free market."

Keynes' real sin was naming the monster that caused the Great Depression, the same monster that caused the current depression.